Ohio Uses Wrong Tool in Brain Drain Battle

by
Lauren Silverman
Tuesday, November 3, 2009
Columbus, Ohio (Photo from sxc.hu)

Columbus, Ohio (Photo from sxc.hu)

Brain-drain states have come up with a whole host of incentives to try and keep young graduates in state. Ohio’s most recent initiative to counter brain drain is called the “Grants for Grads Program.” The program gives down payment aid to graduates to encourage them to buy a house in Ohio. Louisiana has a similar program in place for graduates.

Michigan should not follow Ohio’s lead. After graduation, students leave Rust Belt states such as Ohio and Michigan in search of job opportunities, not housing. Students want to explore and see other places; requiring them to settle down where they grew up within six months after graduation (as requires the Grants for Grads Program) is ridiculous and won’t work.

“What most distinguishes successful areas from Michigan is their concentrations of talent.” – Michigan Future

Research from Michigan Future, a local think tank, has shown that young people value very different things when they’re choosing where to live and where to work. While older people might be looking for a nice house in a safe neighborhood, younger people are looking for nice apartments in exciting neighborhoods with great bars, restaurants and other amenities.

So instead of spending money to force graduates to buy a house they can’t afford and don’t really want, states such as Louisiana and Ohio should be focused on building new urban spaces and generating jobs –- which will really attract young people.

Below: Michigan Future produced this video called “What makes a state prosperous?”


Similar Posts:

746 views
Recommend Recommend (0)
Loading ... Loading ...
Email This Post Email This Post
  • grich
    Really great points. Do you know if Ohio is pursuing other strategies for keeping graduates in-state? Different things matter to different people so taking a multi-faceted approach would make sense in this case - and housing discounts may be PART of the solution. As a previously out-of-state Michigan student, I imagine having a student loan easement plan for out-of-state students would have encouraged my sticking around.

    Unfortunately building a vibrant culture in a city center does not happen over night.
blog comments powered by Disqus